How NCAA Athletes and Brands Can Avoid Big Mistakes in NIL Influencer Agreements | Troutman Pepper

How NCAA Athletes and Brands Can Avoid Big Mistakes in NIL Influencer Agreements | Troutman Pepper

[co-author: Nicole Demas]

The greatest occasion of the 12 months in school sports activities simply concluded as nationwide champions had been topped in males’s and ladies’s basketball, and a whole bunch of 1000’s of school athletes are coming into the influencer market for the primary time. College athletes now discover themselves enticing candidates in the quick rising influencer advertising and marketing area. Industry consultants estimate that this market grew to a $13.8 billion business in 2021, with NCAA athlete promoting alone predicted to develop to $1 billion a 12 months inside 5 years. With influencer advertising and marketing probably offering a 5x return on funding, many manufacturers are desperate to get into the business, but it surely would not come with out dangers. With the FTC Commissioner taking a better take a look at the usage of influencers for advertising and marketing, scholar athletes and manufacturers ought to take care when coming into into the influencer advertising and marketing area. See, ” Statement of Comm’r Rohit Chopra Regarding the Endorsement Guides Review,” Comm’n File No. P204500 (Feb. 12, 2020).

Beginning on July 1, 2021, NCAA athletes had been capable of begin creating wealth from offers that embody their Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL). This was a significant change. Previously, athletes who wished to play for groups in the NCAA couldn’t revenue from their NIL with out dropping novice standing, and thus their alternative to play. This change took place after states started passing NIL laws and the NCAA misplaced 9-0 on the Supreme Court in the Alston case. NCAA v. Alston, 141 S. Ct. 2141, 2153 (2021). While the Alston case handled the NCAA’s restrictions of education-related-benefits on an antitrust foundation, and not particularly NIL, the opinion and concurrence broadly signaled that any subsequent circumstances coping with the NCAA’s restrictions of scholar compensation can be unlikely to finish in the NCAA’s favor. Thirty states have NIL laws at present in impact, with six extra payments set to enter impact by 2025. The legal guidelines and insurance policies round monetizing NIL differ by state and faculty, and have left a patchwork for scholar athletes to navigate going ahead.

As a outcome, the NCAA adopted an “interim” coverage in late June 2021 in response to those legal guidelines going into impact, a scarcity of federal legislative motion, and the end result of Alston. The coverage permits school athletes to revenue from their NIL whereas sustaining their novice standing below the NCAA bylaws. This coverage will keep in impact till federal laws or new NCAA guidelines are adopted. But, it appears unlikely {that a} federal framework shall be in place anytime quickly. Though lawmakers have launched six totally different NIL payments on a federal stage during the last two years, most dying in committee, Congress has been unable to succeed in a compromise on the scope of such a invoice. With this in thoughts, manufacturers want to concentrate on each the state legal guidelines and faculty guidelines that govern earlier than coming into into an settlement.

Additionally, in November 2019, the FTC adopted new tips for influencers and manufacturers. See, ” FTC Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers” (Nov. 2019). Shortly thereafter, in February 2020, the FTC introduced elevated scrutiny on the influencer advertising and marketing area, with Commissioner Rohit Chopra calling for harder cures for firms “AstroTurfing,” i.e., having influencers launch paid advertisements that appear like unsolicited evaluations. See, . The FTC’s assertion put manufacturers on discover of the company’s aim to “be forward-looking to cease fraud from festering” and signaled the Commissioner’s intent to hunt harder cures for firms participating in misleading promoting.

For scholar athletes, there are different issues. While the FTC indicated a deal with pursuing motion towards advertisers, not “small influencers,” influencers should be held personally liable by different firms or customers for false promoting or trademark infringement.

Company/Brand Considerations


Just like another promoting deal, a scholar athlete influencer settlement must be complete and signed by each events. Make certain scholar athletes signal these agreements slightly than informally accepting, e.g., by way of direct message. While some colleges are actively concerned in arranging NIL offers, different state legal guidelines forbid the observe, and nonetheless different colleges is not going to facilitate relationships between manufacturers and their scholar athletes to keep away from the battle of curiosity. This implies that scholar athletes must both be contacted instantly, or by means of one of many quite a few third-party companies which have been working since July. Before coming into into an settlement with a scholar athlete, be sure that to obviously talk the targets and expectations of the influencer contract and put together the contract to replicate that. Consider how lengthy the connection will final, what limits there are on the timing of posts, and what the athlete can and can’t say. Keep in thoughts the aim of bringing goodwill to the model by means of the association.

Standard contractual clauses must be double-checked to make sure coordination and compliance with the model’s enterprise and authorized targets. Brands must also think about the variations in state NIL legal guidelines when incorporating selection of regulation clauses into their agreements. For instance, whereas the California NIL invoice doesn’t permit for contracts that battle with the “athletes group contract,” the Texas NIL invoice goes even additional and doesn’t permit for any contracts that battle with “a provision of an institutional contract of the establishment, a coverage of the athletic division of the establishment, or a provision of the respect code of the establishment.” S.B. 26, Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. (Ca. 2019); S.B. 1385, Gen. Assemb., Reg. Sess. (Tx. 2021). As a outcome, a California contract could not work in Texas.

Additionally, manufacturers ought to think about totally different school and college insurance policies earlier than coming into into promoting agreements. For instance, some schools don’t allow athletes to put on any faculty branded gear in reference to promotion alternatives. See, Georgia Southern University, Name, Image & Likeness Guidance and FAQ (Sept. 3 2021). Other colleges restrict the sorts of manufacturers athletes may go with. See, UMass Student-Athlete Name, Image & Likeness (NIL) Plan (July 1, 2021).

As legal responsibility can stream from the influencer to the model, manufacturers ought to think about whether or not to incorporate an indemnification clause defending them from any false or deceptive statements made by the influencer. Conversely, manufacturers must also perceive the advantages and dangers of both indemnifying or not indemnifying an influencer. For instance, a model could select to incorporate an indemnification clause protecting legal responsibility ensuing from the model’s actions, to probably keep away from a public relations drawback (or retain larger management over litigation technique) if a competitor or client sues a scholar athlete.

Required Disclosures

Brands ought to present each influencer with clear and easy directions for the best way to disclose their relationship with the model to their followers. The FTC requires that influencers point out clearly, in easy language, {that a} put up is a paid advert. But if a paid advert appears like an unpaid evaluation, the FTC could take motion and impose penalties on the model, together with stop and desist orders, fines, or, probably, civil penalties below new steering from Commissioner Chopra.

Influencer Content

Liability for misleading promoting relies on the content material of the advertisements. Brands are subsequently chargeable for claims made about their services or products made by influencers. Even if an advertiser discontinues the misleading or unfair observe, the FTC will sometimes nonetheless proceed with proceedings, particularly if the observe is simply discontinued after changing into conscious of FTC scrutiny. For instance, in December 2019, Teami confronted an FTC enforcement motion not just for making unsupported well being claims, but additionally for influencers who weren’t adequately disclosing their relationship with the model. FTC v. Teami, LLC, No. 8:20-cv-00518 (M.D. Fla. R. 2019). The courtroom ordered the model to carefully monitor influencers and instantly terminate any who didn’t adjust to disclosure necessities. The courtroom additional issued a greater than $15 million judgment in favor of the FTC.

To assist mitigate the chance of an FTC motion, manufacturers ought to think about implementing an affordable coaching, monitoring, and compliance program for his or her influencer promoting community. For instance, manufacturers could profit from educating their influencers on common promoting do’s and don’ts. Providing robust, constant, and well-regulated model tips with any settlement, gifted product, or different promoting relationship could assist keep away from potential false or misleading promoting claims.

Brands must also think about having an lawyer evaluation any scripts despatched to influencers and implement a program to observe compliance. Though a model could worth and, in reality, search out influencers who put their very own spin on the model’s message to higher interact with their viewers, it ought to nonetheless fastidiously steadiness the advantages of influencers “going off script” with the potential dangers. To that finish, manufacturers ought to implement a transparent technique to observe what their influencers are saying and take corrective measures if its influencers violate FTC or model tips. This is particularly essential, on condition that one report discovered the overwhelming majority of high superstar influencer endorsements didn’t comply with FTC guidelines., 93% of Top Celebrity Social Media Endorsements Violate FTC Guidelines, (final visited Mar. 21, 2022).

Brands have selections on how a lot management they exert over influencer content material. Options vary from proactively reviewing advertisements earlier than they’re posted, to reactively taking down advertisements that don’t adjust to FTC or model tips. The most suitable choice for a model will differ, relying on the quantity and sort of influencers in addition to the model’s sources.

Student Athletes Considerations

How Should I Deal With the Contract?

Read the complete doc. If a time period is complicated, do not be afraid to ask or search out an expert service supplier (e.g., an lawyer, agent, guide, tax advisor) for assist. Make certain the settlement is in a separate doc, not only a DM. This means that you can totally evaluation all the pieces the settlement covers. Understand the tax penalties of the settlement. Since influencers could possible be thought of contractors slightly than staff, scholar athletes may very well be chargeable for paying federal and state taxes on their very own.

Also examine in case your state has particular NIL legal guidelines that have to be adopted. For instance, Georgia’s NIL invoice doesn’t permit scholar athletes to enter into contracts that battle with the scholar athlete’s group contracts. As a outcome, a scholar athlete in Georgia could need to think about checking with their faculty earlier than coming into an settlement. Also, colleges could have additional guidelines that have to be adopted. Many colleges make these guidelines simply obtainable on-line .

Some colleges will assist athletes discover NIL contracts. Keep in thoughts that, not like an expert service supplier, the varsity doesn’t work for the athlete and will possible be extra protecting of the varsity’s pursuits than the athletes. Some regulation colleges supply sports activities regulation clinics, which might present an athlete with authorized recommendation at no cost. And even when you do not suppose you will have the bargaining energy to barter particular person phrases, be sure to perceive the phrases and determine if it is a deal you really need.

What Do I Have to Disclose?

If you’re employed with manufacturers to suggest or endorse their merchandise, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) requires you to reveal that your put up is a paid advert. The FTC’s tips for social media influencers require that the disclosure:

Be clearly positioned and not hidden, g., in hashtags or the underside of the put up. Superimpose it over photographs and movies and say it slowly and clearly in audio.
Use easy, clear language. Stay away from abbreviations or complicated language.
Clearly point out your relationship with the model, g., a gifted product and/or a sponsored advert.

While the FTC could deal with pursuing authorized motion towards manufacturers slightly than particular person influencers, failing to reveal your relationship with the model could violate the model’s tips, and could trigger the model to terminate your settlement.

What (Not) to Say in Ads?

There could also be authorized penalties to what you say in advertisements. To keep away from participating in misleading promoting, do not say issues in regards to the product that are not true. Brands could provide you with a script of what to say. When you get the script, do not be afraid to ask follow-up questions. If the script makes claims in regards to the effectiveness of a product, ask the place that info got here from. If the product doesn’t work because the script says, speak to the model in regards to the declare. If a product script says it smells nice, but it surely smells like rotten eggs while you obtain it, do not simply say it smells nice. Again, examine with the model to see that you just acquired the precise product. If you bought the precise product and it doesn’t work or it smells horrible, do not make claims on the contrary.

Make certain you perceive the best way to speak to a model about this earlier than you enter into the settlement. Also, if a product deliberately tries to appear like one other product (e.g., a knockoff or “nice dupe”), it is best to not take that deal. By taking affordable steps to guard your self, and by ensuring you aren’t saying one thing false or deceptive, it reduces (although would not remove) the potential of a false promoting lawsuit.

How Will the Brand Enforce Guidelines?

Brands monitor their advertisements in alternative ways. Know how the manufacturers you’re employed with will monitor your posts. Find out if the model must approve a put up earlier than it goes up, or if they’ll power you to take a put up down. If it is not clear from the phrases of the settlement, ask. Understand what’s and is not acceptable from the model’s viewpoint. If they provide a script, it might be in your greatest curiosity to stay to it, each to take care of a great relationship with the model and to guard your self from authorized legal responsibility.

Can I Be Held Legally Liable?

In brief, sure. Know that promoting exercise can result in lawsuits. If you make a false assertion a few product, infringe on a trademark, or fail to comply with FTC tips, a lawsuit might comply with. Factor that in when deciding whether or not or to not settle for an settlement. A model could or could not indemnify an advertiser from private legal responsibility for promoting. Indemnification can imply that the model agrees to take monetary and obligation for lawsuits ensuing from an advert. It is a clause in your settlement that could be price mentioning in the negotiation section, so you possibly can totally weigh the dangers of coming into into an settlement.


Influencer promoting for NCAA athletes stands to change into an enormous market with potential advantages for each manufacturers and scholar athletes. However, each ought to tread fastidiously, because the FTC has signaled an intent to step up its monitoring and enforcement. A patchwork of state NIL legal guidelines provides complexity to scholar athlete influencer agreements, and manufacturers ought to seek the advice of with their authorized and enterprise groups. Student athletes must also take care when signing an endorsement or promoting settlement, and ought to strongly think about profiting from the NCAA Policy permitting them to “use an expert providers supplier for NIL actions,” together with a authorized service supplier.

This article was printed in the April 2022 version of the Intellectual Property Strategist and is republished right here with permission.

You May Also Like

About the Author: Amanda