Quality, constant and easy messaging is what is going to usher in gross sales. The relaxation is simply noise.
What makes for profitable social media advertising and marketing? Is it messaging that creates pleasure or leans in direction of the informative? Stunning visuals and/or stirring music? Celebrity influencers and their stamp of approval? And how does all of it have an effect on gross sales anyway?
Identifying the components of efficient social media messaging is important, contemplating that 3.6 billion individuals use social media, and social media advert spend is on monitor to surpass US$200 billion by 2024. In a groundbreaking research, my co-authors* and I examine the affect of differing kinds of firm-generated content material (FGC) on the product gross sales of a big shopper electronics multinational over two years. We discovered that hedonic messaging, which seeks to evoke enjoyable, playfulness, enjoyment and pleasure, elevated gross sales greater than utilitarian ones, which emphasise merchandise’ performance. Importantly, this impact got here by solely when the message was easy and of ample high quality and consistency.
Our research, the first to research hedonic and utilitarian FGC approaches in the context of a big agency, underscores the significance of coherent and built-in advertising and marketing communication based mostly on the rules of high quality, consistency and ease.
The research
The topic of our research is a significant world shopper electronics and manufacturing agency, which agreed to be concerned on situation of anonymity. It offered us with its each day gross sales income, measured in US {dollars}, for every product in our evaluation of its 2016–2017 advertising and marketing and gross sales programme database. During the two-year interval, the agency engaged with prospects on its Facebook web page and Twitter account.
We retrieved all firm-generated content material on each social media platforms in addition to shopper feedback, posts, shares, and “likes”. Then, we manually analysed if the posts have been hedonic or utilitarian in addition to their high quality, consistency and complexity. We additionally analysed customers’ reactions to the FGC. Below are our standards for every metric:
Hedonic or utilitarian
Utilitarian messages emphasised the product’s sensible advantages, similar to finishing particular duties effectively and successfully and informing customers how to resolve particular issues with the product. Hedonic ones highlighted the product as bringing enjoyable, enjoyment and pleasure. They have been experiential and multisensory in addition to imaginative and aspirational.
Message high quality
Message high quality is measured by the common rating of three unbiased specialists’ ranking of every message, from 0 to 10, in phrases of uniqueness, novelty and believability.
Message objective consistency
Message objective consistency is measured by the common ranking of three evaluators who independently assessed every message on whether or not it was suitable, constant and congruous with the agency’s model picture of “cutting-edge, future-oriented, tech-savvy innovation, world-class and experiential”.
Message complexity
Message complexity was measured by readability of the advertising and marketing content material. For every product, we used the imply readability rating (calculated with the Dale–Chall formulation) of the agency’s Facebook and Twitter posts to gauge the messages’ complexity.
Keep it easy, preserve it constant
Our evaluation exhibits that hedonic messaging boosted product efficiency – measured in phrases of each day gross sales income – greater than utilitarian messaging. But what’s much more noteworthy is that message high quality and message objective consistency performed a decisive function in figuring out the advertising and marketing final result.
Whether the messaging was hedonic or utilitarian, the posts had to attain a sure stage of high quality and consistency earlier than they started to have a optimistic affect on gross sales. The minimal high quality rating for hedonic messaging was 4 (out of 10) and 6 for utilitarian ones. For each varieties of messaging, the minimal consistency rating was 0.
Further, message high quality affected the affect of hedonic messaging greater than that of utilitarian ones.
Put merely, high-quality messaging boosted the agency’s gross sales extra when the messaging was hedonic quite than utilitarian, whereas poor-quality messaging broken gross sales extra when the messaging was hedonic. Message consistency had comparable moderating impact on the two varieties of advertising and marketing appeals.
How to make nice content material
While there’s a rising physique of analysis on FGC, our research is the first empirical check of the effectiveness of high quality, constant and easy on-line advertising and marketing communication on product gross sales.
So how would possibly companies obtain the holy grail of distinctive, constant and easy-to-comprehend messaging? They may begin by asking the following questions:
1. Is the content material compelling?
FGC ought to present worth by serving to customers clear up their issues, reply their questions and considerations, pique and increase their pursuits, or construct belief in the product. The most profitable FGC on social media additionally engages with customers, together with responding to buyer feedback.
2. Does the content material circulate properly aesthetically and logically?
Users gained’t click on on content material that isn’t entertaining, intriguing or informative, so use differing kinds of media together with photographs, movies, music and infographics. But watch out not to neglect the fundamentals – spelling and grammatical errors can harm credibility, regardless of how good the messaging is in any other case.
3. Is the content material aligned with the agency’s total branding?
Consistent messaging is aligned with what the model stands for, its worth proposition and function. It additionally adheres to the model DNA in phrases of model and tone. Consistent FGC makes the model extra recognisable and credible to customers.
Of course, all that hinge on whether or not companies have clear model positioning and a set of branding tips for all staff in addition to exterior companions. This will assist be certain that the look, tone, terminology and framing of FGC throughout all merchandise, themes, markets and platforms are constant.
Take it from Apple. The “world’s most beneficial model” has few rivals in crafting meticulously curated messages that reinforce its central identification of creating smooth and stylish merchandise that push the boundaries of innovation. Another function mannequin is Walmart, which by no means fails to emphasise in its FGC its low costs and worth creation for prospects.
Conversely, FGC that diverges from the model positioning sends combined indicators to customers. Many car manufacturers fall into this entice: While the model’s personal content material normally conveys a slick, skilled picture, the native vendor’s messaging is usually unprofessional and poorly executed.
4. Is the content material concise and well-articulated?
Strong, memorable FGC is characterised by crisp, persuasive and clear writing. It evokes optimistic feelings and helps prospects visualise how they may profit from utilizing the agency’s services or products. For this purpose, it’s a good suggestion to check content material for readability earlier than posting it on social media.
Remember, the extra advanced the content material is, the extra probably it will likely be ignored.
*Jifeng Mu, Alabama A&M University; Jonathan Zhang, Colorado State University College of Business; and Jiayin Qi, Shanghai University of International Business & Economics
Abhishek Borah is an INSEAD Assistant Professor of Marketing.
INSEAD Knowledge is now on LinkedIn. Join the dialog at the moment.
Follow INSEAD Knowledge on Twitter and Facebook.
https://information.insead.edu/advertising and marketing/how-to-shoot-for-the-holy-grail-of-social-media-marketing-19136
